That One - Whisper Word

My grandmother was born in 1903 (the year the Wright brothers got one of those aeroplane contraptions off the ground for the first time) and died in 1995.  The only time she ever voted for a Democrat was in, get this, 1980 for Jimmy Carter; because he waved at her from his motorcade as he passed by our house - she felt a connection.  Aside from that one instance, she clung to her grandfather's advice that it was the Republicans who fought for the common man -- despite my teenage insistence that the tables had turned.

The closest she probably ever came to getting to know a black man was the one time I brought my 32 year-old, graduate student housemate back to my parents' home in the early ninety's.  She said, "He's a nice black boy."

So, what's this whole diary about?  Well it's obvious my grandmother was a racist.  She didn't mean to be.  She certainly didn't think of herself as one.  After all, she voted Republican, didn't she?  My whole young life, however, I heard about "that one."

To give it some context, it was always used to refer to an outsider.  Usually, invariably, she referred to African-Americans as "that one", or "those people" if it was necessary to group them together.  There was not a lot of call for it in our neighborhood as I was growing up, but occasionally a "that one" would creep into her vocabulary in reference to Hispanics.  Most pointedly, however, she would use it to refer to my 100% Italian father when she was really irritated with him.  After all, she was all German and her late husband all Scots-Irish, so anyone swarthy, dark or, God-forbid Catholic, was certainly "that one" and inherently "other".

When Senator McCain used the phrase in the debate this evening, it conjured up in me an inherent reflex.  I'm sure it was the opposite of what he intended -- in me -- but probably exactly what he wanted in the 55 to 70 age-group; it was a dog whistle indicator that "that one" is someone different.  Let's not mince words...  to my parents' generation he was saying, "This is someone 'other', a black guy, an outsider, someone you can't trust.  In fact, he's the guy, personified, whom you have always blamed for any ill which has befallen you."

Yeah, he said all that in two words.  

I think I'm in a somewhat unique situation here.  I'm the product of two long generations.  I'm a Gen-X'er.  I just turned forty a couple days ago.  But my brother and sister are solidly Boomers in their mid-fifties.  (Yeah, I was an accident, but that's another diary.)  My folks are in their mid-seventies, and thanks to my persistence they're solidly in Obama's camp.  But others in that generation just got the subliminal signal that Obama is one of "those people"...  an "other" if you will.  It's not enough to knock my parents off their (recently) progressive footing, but it's gonna hurt with any seniors or near-seniors who don't have an Obama advocate on hand.  They've heard this kind of talk from their authority figures throughout their upbringing, and it's gonna hit home with some of them.



Display:


Tips? (none / 0)

I don't write a lot of diaries... in fact this is only my second, and the first didn't really have any content.  But this one is, well, anecdotal, it's real life.  Hope ya'll enjoyed it or at least got something from it.


by xeju on Wed Oct 08, 2008 at 03:05:34 AM EST

Re: That One - Whisper Word (none / 0)

My mother-in-law called me and my wife up as soon as he said it. She's early 50's, and I'm a Gen Xer, like you (37).
Yes, it struck a real racial chord with her. (We're all African-American). Actually, that's putting it lightly, she was LIVID!

I've suffered this enough under Bush., but to a certain extent I always gave Bush a racial pass because his actions towards minorites were more from class ignorance rather than a racist root. Obviously, if you are his friend, or agreed with him or  had money, he likes you regardless of color. I can tolerate that.

McCain has always had to prove something to me after the MLK episode.

*McCain interacted with two Black males last night. He forgot ones name and called the other "That one". He insulted one's intelligence by insuating that he had never heard of Fanny Mae and Freddie Mac, and he continued a lie on the other one by trying to portray him as naieve and inexperienced and unknown. *

I'm sick of it, damnit.

THe Republican's need a new playbook, because this one will just make me want to phonebank and canvass more.
 


A PROUD Hopium user!
by xodus1914 on Wed Oct 08, 2008 at 11:01:28 AM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.